L. Neil Smith's
THE LIBERTARIAN ENTERPRISE
Number 61, December 15, 1999
Happy Bill of Rights Day!
But No Honest Citizen Needs a Gun ... Right?
by Vin Suprynowicz
Special to TLE
One of the staple mantras of the gun grabbers -- we're not supposed
to think about it (since statistics show it's 99 percent wrong), just
chant it until is lulls us into a feeling of sweet repose -- is that
"If you own a firearm you're just as likely to have it taken away and
used against you."
I guess that's why I took so quickly to a new book which Floyd Coons
at Master Shooters Supply handed me the other day.
"The Best Defense: True Stories of Intended Victims Who Defended Themselves With a Firearm,"
is by Robert A. Waters, a retired vocational rehabilitation
counselor from Ocala Florida ($14.95 from Cumberland House, 431
Harding Industrial Drive, Nashville 37211.)
I defy anyone to dismiss these 14 harrowing, true-life accounts,
often told in the words of the very crime victims who survived their
ordeals due to one common factor: The fact that in America, we have a
right to bear arms.
Take the case of 49-year-old divorcee Sammie Foust of Cape Coral,
Fla. "I used to love to open the windows and doors and feel the gulf
breezes flowing through my house," Ms. Foust told interviewer Waters.
"I got pleasure from watching sailboats pass by in the canal behind
my home. Now I sit in a closed-up room. I'm even afraid to answer the
Foust had fallen asleep cleaning house on the evening of May 9, 1996.
The bed where she lay was piled with bags of old clothing she'd
decided to give away, along with old purses and boxes of odds and
In her housecleaning, she'd also come across a tiny .25 caliber
semiautomatic handgun a friend had long ago insisted she take for
self-defense, though Sammie's father had warned her it was too small,
advising: "Get a bigger gun. Wounded dogs will bite you. Dead dogs
The magazine of the .25 held four rounds. She'd checked it the night
before, snapped the little slide to chamber the top round, and then
fallen asleep with the little gun next to her pile of pillows.
When she heard the blinds rattle in the living room at dawn, she
assumed it was her cat returning. But it wasn't. It was three-time
prison inmate James Wayne Horne, who had been released for the third
time only a few weeks before, after serving slightly more than one
year of a 10-year sentence for aggravated assault.
The robber-assailant rushed into the bedroom and slashed Foust's face
with a box-cutter knife.
She offered him her purse, which he dumped on the bed, finding $400
in bills. He then demanded Foust tell him the location of her jewelry
box, which she did. But the man was upset with the cheap quality of
the costume jewelry, returning to demand "her diamonds" and to
continue viciously slashing and beating her about the face.
"You know I'm going to kill you," he hissed. "So you might as well
give it up. Die easy or die hard, bitch."
Foust directed the man to a second credenza. She knew it contained
only more costume jewelry, but she needed space and time. Time to
pick up the little .25, which she was amazed her assailant had not
spotted ... and to figure out what to do with it.
You see, Sammie Foust had never fired a gun in her life.
She aimed for the man's center of mass and pulled the trigger. It
sounded like a little cap pistol. There was no recoil, no blood. The
man did not fly backwards or keel over dead. She figured the gun had
But she'd certainly managed to upset James Wayne Horne, who flew back
across the room, punching her square in the face. "She literally
heard her nose implode back into her skull," Waters reports.
"Dear God, she prayed, don't let me pass out. Dear God,
please let me hold onto this gun."
The assailant pulled her to her feet, grabbed her wrist, and tried to
wrench the gun away her with one hand while pummeling her with
jackhammer blows to the face with his other fist. Police later told
her James Wayne Horne had knocked out four of her teeth, which she'd
swallowed. The bones in her gums were crushed, and her left cheekbone
was fractured. Her nose was broken and her larynx fractured. Horne
pounded and slashed at her face with his knife until one eyeball was
hanging out of its socket.
But he did not get the gun.
Assuming her first two shots had missed, Foust resolved to save her
two remaining cartridges until she had a clear shot. Finally, as the
man drew back his arm for a knockout punch, she pointed the .25 at
his stomach and fired again.
"Bitch!" he whispered, as he dragged her into the living room and
continued beating her. ""Now I'm gonna take that gun and blow your
Instead, Foust shot Horne a fourth time, in the abdomen.
With the man atop her, pounding and pounding, Sammie Foust believed
she could not survive. But finally, James Wayne Horne lay still.
When police arrived, they found tables knocked over, chairs broken,
dishes shattered, the walls and floors smeared with blood.
They found James Wayne Horne where she had left him. The medical
examiner concluded the first shot had entered his mouth, the second
his heart, the third and fourth bullets his abdomen and groin. He had
taken nearly an hour to bleed to death.
Sammie Foust noticed the police and ambulance personnel wincing
whenever they looked at her, cursing her attacker under their breath.
When she finally found a mirror, she realized why. Her eye was
surgically reattached that day, and permanent loss of sight was
minimal. She has since run out of funds to pay for the proper repair
of her gums and teeth. To this day, she eats only soft food.
As an afterthought, as they hauled James Wayne Horne's body away,
Sammie Foust pulled her hand from her pocket and asked a police
interviewer: "Would you like to have this?"
Foust recalled for author Waters: "A policeman came back and knelt
down on the driveway. He tried to pry my fingers from the gun. And he
started crying and said 'I'm gonna break your fingers. I can't get
them loose.' But I couldn't let go of the handle. My knuckles were
swollen up, I was holding it so tight. The grip I had on that gun was
what kept my attacker from getting it from me. Even as big a man as
he was, he couldn't take it away."
And here I thought people like Sammie Foust would be better off if we
banned all handguns. Because if she had a handgun, you see, it would
just as likely be taken away and used against her.
Vin Suprynowicz is assistant editorial page editor of the Las Vegas
Review-Journal. His new book,
Send in the Waco Killers, is available at 1-800-244-2224.
to return to the previous article, or
Table of Contents
to return to The Libertarian Enterprise, Number 61, December 15, 1999.